3108 6 Mile Road, Caledonia, WI 53402 262-456-2348 Open 7 Days A Week

Everly's Ice Cream

Skip the line and Order Online or use Door Dash

  • Home
  • Our Creative Creations
  • Order online
  • Apply Here!
  • More
    • Home
    • Our Creative Creations
    • Order online
    • Apply Here!
Everly's Ice Cream

Skip the line and Order Online or use Door Dash

  • Home
  • Our Creative Creations
  • Order online
  • Apply Here!

Get the inside scoop at everly's

Get the inside scoop at everly'sGet the inside scoop at everly'sGet the inside scoop at everly's

May Flavor: Banana Cream Pie Ice Cream.  Come enjoy our creative new items, flavor choices, and monthly specials.  

Get the inside scoop at everly's

Get the inside scoop at everly'sGet the inside scoop at everly'sGet the inside scoop at everly's

May Flavor: Banana Cream Pie Ice Cream.  Come enjoy our creative new items, flavor choices, and monthly specials.  

May Special Deals

#

Flavor Alert: Black Licorice

Licorice Flavored Ice Cream Black Licorice Pieces

#

May 24-26! Patriot Donut Split

Blue Moon, Vanilla, Strawberry Ice Cream, Donut

#

Flavor Alert: Strawberry

Strawberry Swirled with Real Strawberry Pieces

Flavor of the Month: Banana Cream Pie

It's Here! No Fat-No Sugar added ice cream Cups

Available In-Store Now: No Fat-No Sugar Added Ice Cream Cups.  Your Choice of Strawberry Twist or Plain Vanilla. Three Ounces of Guilt Free Ice Cream with All the Sweetness You'll Enjoy!  Only $1.25 Each

Did you know you can create your own custom ice CREAM CAKE?

Create Your Own Ice Cream Cake That Will Please All Palates.  Choose Your Soft Serve Flavor, Add Your Selection of Toppings, and Your Sauce.  These can also be made Gluten Free. All Custom Cake Orders Are Taken In-Store Only and Require a 5 Day Lead Time. Visit Store for More Details. 

Paisley's Premium's Ice Cream Cakes

The "Dirty Turtle"

The " Cheesecake Berry Blast"

The " Cheesecake Berry Blast"

This Gluten Free Option is Made with Our Delicious Chocolate Soft Serve Ice Cream. Loaded with Pecans, Ghirardelli Chocolate and Caramel Sauces and Trimmed with Chocolate Buttercream Icing.  Available in store or for order online. 

* 8 Inch Shown * Serves 8-10  

6 inch $22    8 inch $28

The " Cheesecake Berry Blast"

The " Cheesecake Berry Blast"

The " Cheesecake Berry Blast"

Vanilla Soft Serve Ice Cream Blended with Cheesecake Bites and Graham Crackers. Middle Layer Contains Frozen Diced Strawberries and Strawberry Sauce.  More Cheesecake Bites and Strawberry Sauce Top This Tasty Treat.  Trimmed with Vanilla Buttercream Icing.   

 *6 Inch Shown * Serves 6-8 

6 inch $22   8 inch $28

The "Mudslide"

The " Cheesecake Berry Blast"

The "Mudslide"

Chocolate Lovers Dream Cake!

Chocolate Soft Serve Ice Cream Blended with Brownie Pieces.  Middle Layer Contains Brownie Chunks and Ghirardelli Chocolate Sauce.  Topped with Chocolate Crunch and Chocolate Sauce Trimmed with Chocolate Buttercream Icing. 

* 8 Inch Shown *Serves 8-10

6 inch $22    8 inch $28

6 Inch only $22 or 8 Inch Only $28

The "Peanut Butter Dream"

The "Peanut Butter Dream"

The "Peanut Butter Dream"

Calling All Peanut Butter Lovers!  

This Vanilla Soft Serve Ice Cream Cake Features Blended Reese's Pieces, Reese's Peanut Butter Cups and Reese's Peanut Butter Sauce All Tucked Inside.  Topped with Reese's Pieces and Reese's Peanut Butter Sauce and Trimmed with Vanilla Buttercream Frosting. *6 Inch Shown *Serves 6-8

The "Cookie Overload"

The "Peanut Butter Dream"

The "Peanut Butter Dream"

Our Most Popular Ice Cream Cake.  

Vanilla Soft Serve Ice Cream Blended with Oreo Cookies in Bottom Layer.  Middle Layer Contains Our Delicious Chocolate Chunk Cookie Pieces and Ghirardelli Chocolate Sauce.  Vanilla Soft Serve, Oreos, and Ghirardelli Chocolate Sauce Complete This Treat.  Trimmed with Vanilla Buttercream Icing.  *8 Inch Shown *Serves 8-10

The "Cosmic Candy"

The "Peanut Butter Dream"

The "Cosmic Candy"

This Ice Cream Cake is Out of This World!  

This Vanilla Soft Serve Ice Cream Cake is Blended with Loads of Sprinkles in the Bottom Layer.  Middle Layer Contains Frosted Sprinkled Donut Pieces.   Topped with Your Choice of In Stock Pop Rocks Flavors and Trimmed with Colored Vanilla Buttercream Icing.  *6 Inch Shown *Serves 6-8 

We are the place that is always "Happily Everly After!"

Hand Scoop Ice Cream

Cedarcrest Hand Scoop Ice Cream with Delicious Mix-ins

Paisley's Premium Shakes

Decadent Shakes with Rimming Around the Cup, Whip Cream, Drizzle, and a Large Topper.  Made To Order or Create Your Own One-of-a-Kind Shake.

Regular Shakes and Malts

Hand Scooped Ice Cream from Cedarcrest. Made with Whole Milk and Blended.  Make It a Malt for only $1 More.

Cones and Dishes

Delicious Flavors of Hand Scoop Ice Cream Paired with Our Traditional Cake Cones or Choose a Deliciously Made -In- House Waffle Cone or Bowl for only $1 More.  Each Dish or Cone Comes with One Topping.  Many Flavors to Choose From.

Ice Cream Sundaes

An Everly's Version of a Traditional Sundae with Two Hand Scooped Servings of Ice Cream Flavor of Your Choice, Served in Our Made-In-House Waffle Bowl with Large topper, Choice of Sauce, and Whip.

Ice Cream Sandwiches

One Hand Scoop Ice Cream Flavor of Your Choice Nestled Between Two Freshly Baked Cookies.   

Donut Splits

Long John Donut Split Open and Filled with up to Three Flavors of Hand Scoop Ice Cream with One Topping, One Sauce, and Whip.

Everly's Ice Cream Pints-to-Go

Skip the Line and Grab a Pint-to-Go.  No Worries...Any of Our Cedarcrest Flavors Can Be Sold to You in a Pint.

Gluten Free and Dairy Free Options

Made in House gluten free chocolate or vanilla waffle bowls and cones are great to pair with our multiple gluten hard scoop flavors. We also carry pint varieties such as Ben and Jerry's dairy free and Cedarcrest dairy free Mango, Raspberry, and Lemon Sorbets.

No Fat-No Sugar ADDED OPTIONS

No Fat-No Sugar Added Ice Cream Cups have All the Sweetness and Creaminess of Regular Ice Cream but Without the Guilt.  Individual Three Ounce Cups in Strawberry Twist or Vanilla Flavors. Available in store now!


Soft Serve Ice Cream

Soft Serve Ice Cream Made With Whole Milk

Waffle Nachos

Your Choice of Vanilla, Chocolate, or Twist Soft Serve Ice Cream. Choose Your Sauce Flavor.  Add Fifty Cents for Each Additional Topping or Whip 

Waffle Tacos

                *Available Tuesdays Only*

Your Choice of Vanilla, Chocolate, or Twist Soft Serve.  Choose Your Sauce, Topping, and Whip.  Choose Between GLUTEN FREE, Vanilla, or Chocolate Shell

Flavor Fusion Soft Serve Shakes

Delicious Soft Serve Ice Cream Shakes With Mix-Ins and Sauces Blended To Perfection.

Ice Cream Cones and Dishes

Chocolate, Vanilla, and Twist Ice Cream Made with Whole Milk Served in A Cake Cone or Dish.  Add a Made-In-House Waffle Cone or Bowl For $1 More.

Soft Serve Dipped Cones

Small or Medium Chocolate, Vanilla, or Twist Cone Dipped in Cherry, Chocolate, or Blue Raspberry Cone Dip.  Only .50 Cents More

Declan's Dippers Mini Dipped Cones

3-Ounce Mini Chocolate, Vanilla, or Twist Cone Dipped in Cherry, Chocolate, or Blue Raspberry Cone Dip.  Only $1.00 

Ice Cream Sundae

Two Small Servings Served in a Waffle Bowl with a Large Topper, Sauce, and Whip.

Banana Split

Three Servings of Soft Serve Flavor of Your Choice with One Split Banana, Topped with Chocolate and Strawberry Sauce, Pineapple, Whip Cream, and Three Cherries on Top.

Root Beer Floats

Traditional Vanilla Soft Serve Ice Cream with A & W Root Beer Soda. 

Real Fruit Smoothies

Real Frozen Fruit Blended with Vanilla Soft Serve Ice Cream and Blended with Torani Syrups.

Soft Serve Vanilla Pup Cup

One Serving of Vanilla Soft Serve for Our Furry Pals.  Served with a doggie treat.                               


Coffee and Tea

A Complete Selection of Coffee and Tea to Please All Connoisseurs.  Each can be served Hot or Iced.  Available in Mochas, Lattes, Americano, Macchiatos, Cappuccino, Frozen Coffee, and Hot Chocolate. 

Tea also available hot or iced.  Please see menu for list of flavors.

Paisley's Premium's Lattes

Over the Top Lattes Served Hot or Iced with Muddled Candy Bar and Flavored syrups.   Choose from Heath Bar, Oreo, Snickers, and Peanut Butter Cup.  16 ounces of pure goodness! 

Coffee Flights

Choose Any Three of Our Coffees or Paisley's Premium Lattes, Hot or Iced for a Special Price. Great to Share with Friends for That Morning Cup of Joe.                    


Declan's Delights Bakery Items

Donut Holes                          Jumbo Cake Donuts

Unfilled Long Johns          Cookies

Cupcakes                                Brownies


Enjoy All of Our Baked Goods in Single Quantities.  Need More Than Just One? 

We Can Accommodate Larger Orders 

Upon Request.


Tumblers and Drinkware

Now You Can Drink in Style.  Check Out Our Assortment of Tumblers, Water Bottles, Snack Cups, and More.  Get Yours Today!  They Won't Last Long.                                                

Key chains available in regular cones or fuzzy style.

Key chains and Earrings

Key Chains and Earrings to Please All Ice Cream Lovers.  Key Chains are Glittery Waffle Cones, Fuzzy Waffle Cones or Ring Donuts.  Pierced Earring Selection Style includes Glitter Waffle Cones in Assorted Colors.

Gift Cards are a real treat!

Treat your friends and family to the delicious taste of Everly's Ice Cream with our gift cards. Available for purchase in store in any dollar amount. 

About Everly's Ice Cream

Our Inspiration

Events and Catering

Our Inspiration

Whether young or old, Ice cream always holds a place in our hearts.  We hope to create new memories of the neighborhood ice cream parlor that is fun for all ages.

Our Creations

Events and Catering

Our Inspiration

We're not afraid to get creative with our ice cream creations! We love getting ideas from our customers to help us make new items that are unique and exciting. We have added gluten free cake cones and waffle cones to our menu as well as dairy free ice cream options.

Events and Catering

Events and Catering

Events and Catering

We love sharing our ice cream with the community! We offer catering services for events of all sizes and can incorporate flavors of ice cream and toppings to match any theme.

Contact Us

Drop us a line!

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Better yet, see us in person!

We love our customers, so feel free to visit during normal business hours.

EVERLYSICECREAM.COM

3108 6 Mile Road, Caledonia, Wisconsin 53402

262-456-2348

Hours

Mon

07:00 am – 08:00 pm

Tue

07:00 am – 08:00 pm

Wed

07:00 am – 08:00 pm

Thu

07:00 am – 08:00 pm

Fri

07:00 am – 09:00 pm

Sat

07:00 am – 09:00 pm

Sun

12:00 pm – 08:00 pm

Copyright © 2025 EVERLY'S ICE CREAM.COM - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by

  • Order online
  • Apply Here!